eXp Realty Kathleen Militello, Realtor® The Militello Team COASTAL HOMES & LIVING

Selling Your Home · Straight answer from Kathleen

Should I accept an offer below my asking price?

It depends on the offer, not just the number. A below-asking offer can be the right one to accept when the buyer's terms are strong and the price sits within the range the evidence supports, and a full-price offer can be the wrong one when the terms are weak. The asking price is a starting point, not a verdict on what your home is worth.

Also answered on this page

  • How much below asking is too low to consider?

Start with the comparable sales. What have similar homes in your area actually sold for in the last few months? If the offer lands inside that range, the market is telling you the price is reasonable, even if it sits below the number on your listing.

Then weigh your days on market. A home that has been listed for a while with few showings is priced against what the market has told you, and that feedback deserves real weight. A home with competing interest is in a different position entirely.

Then read the buyer's terms, because they are half the offer. Cash can close faster and with fewer surprises. A strong down payment and a verified preapproval lower financing risk. Fewer contingencies and a flexible closing date can be worth real money to you, sometimes enough to make a lower price the better overall deal.

And ask whether a counteroffer could close the gap. When the difference is small and both sides want to avoid starting over, a middle number is often within reach.

The lowest price is not always the worst offer, and the highest is not always the best. I will go through every line of each offer with you, compare it against the evidence, and help you decide, and negotiate, from a clear picture.

On the North Shore

On the North Shore, pricing strategy shows up directly in the offers you receive. A home priced with a little room can draw offers that land near or below asking, while a home priced at the top of its range invites a different conversation. That is why we talk about the number on the listing and the number that actually makes sense for you.

Still wondering

Ask your own version of this question.

Every situation is different, which is why Kathleen asks questions before she answers them. Send your details and she will reply personally with advice specific to your move.

Kathleen replies personally. Let's talk about what makes sense for you.

Selling Your Home

Ready to make a smart move?

The answer that fits your situation usually needs one more question from Kathleen. That is what the conversation is for.